Carfax vs CleanVins: which should you buy?

CleanVins ($9.99) and Carfax ($49.99) both report NMVTIS title brands, salvage, junk and total-loss records plus NHTSA recalls. CleanVins includes service records from 12,000+ repair shops; Carfax's private network of dealer service visits and insurance-reported minor accidents is larger. CleanVins adds auction photos and records, a rebuilt window sticker and an AI buyer summary, with no subscription. Screen cars with CleanVins; buy a Carfax only if you want its broader service history on the final car.

Same federal title data, a $40 price gap, and one real difference: the size of the service-record network.

Carfax vs CleanVins, side by side

FeatureCarfaxCleanVins
Single report price$49.99$9.99
Three reports$119.99 (4) — no 3-pack$14.99
NMVTIS title brands, salvage, total lossYesYes
NHTSA open recallsYesYes
Odometer readingsYesYes
Dealer service recordsYesNo
Insurance-reported minor accidentsYesPartial
Salvage auction recordsPartialYes
Window-sticker rebuildNoYes
Free VIN decode, no signupNoYes

Competitor prices are publicly listed and change without notice.

When Carfax is worth the extra money

If you are about to buy one specific car and want to see oil changes, dealer visits and small fender-benders that never touched the title, Carfax sees more.

When CleanVins is enough

For checking several cars, or catching the costly problems — salvage, flood, rebuilt title, total loss, odometer issues, open recalls — the $9.99 report covers the same federal records.

From the founder

I started CleanVins because a vehicle history report shouldn't cost $49.99. The title, salvage and recall data behind it comes from federal sources — NHTSA and NMVTIS — so we charge $9.99 once, with no subscription, and put the free checks in front of the paywall where they belong.

— Nolan Shin, Founder & CEO, CleanVins

Related: Best Carfax alternatives for 2027 · Is CleanVins legit? · How much is a Carfax report? · Run a free VIN decode

Pricing

Free: VIN decoding and NHTSA safety recall lookups, unlimited, no signup and no credit card. Paid: a full vehicle history report is $9.99 for one VIN, $14.99 for a 3-report pack and $24.99 for a 10-report pack. One-time payment, no subscription and no auto-renewal.

Frequently asked questions

Is CleanVins cheaper than Carfax?

Yes. CleanVins is $9.99 per report versus $49.99 for Carfax, and $14.99 for three versus $119.99 for Carfax's four-pack.

Does CleanVins use the same data as Carfax?

Both use NMVTIS for title brands and total losses and NHTSA for recalls. Carfax also has its own service-shop and insurer network that CleanVins does not have.

Which should I buy first?

Run CleanVins on every car you are considering, then buy a Carfax only on the car you are about to purchase if you need its service history.

Data sources

CleanVins is not affiliated with Carfax, AutoCheck, NHTSA or NMVTIS.