Carfax vs AutoCheck: which report should you buy?

Carfax ($49.99) is better for privately owned cars with a dealer-service history, because its insurance-carrier and repair-shop network reports accidents no public record captures. AutoCheck ($29.99) is better for auction and ex-fleet cars, because Experian owns Manheim data and adds the AutoCheck Score. Both license the same NHTSA and NMVTIS federal records that CleanVins sells for $9.99.

Two reports, two different private networks, a $15 price gap — and one question that decides it for you: where did the car come from?

Carfax vs AutoCheck vs CleanVins, side by side

FeatureCarfaxAutoCheckCleanVins
Single report price$49.99$29.99$9.99
Multi-report pack$69.99 (2) / $119.99 (4)$59.99 (3)$14.99 (3)
Free VIN decoder, no signupNoNoYes
NHTSA recall lookupYesYesYes
NMVTIS title brands & salvageYesYesYes
Insurance-reported accidentsYesPartialPartial
Dealer service recordsYesPartialPartial
Auction history (Manheim/Copart/IAAI)PartialYesYes
Proprietary scoreNoAutoCheck ScoreRisk summary
Window-sticker rebuildNoNoYes
AI-written buyer summaryNoNoYes
Subscription requiredNoNoNo

Competitor prices are publicly listed single-report prices and change without notice.

The one question that decides it

Carfax and AutoCheck pull the same federal backbone — NHTSA vPIC for build data, NMVTIS for title brands, salvage and total-loss records, NICB for theft. Everything above that line is a private network, and the two companies built very different ones.

Carfax spent three decades signing up insurance carriers, franchise dealers and independent repair shops. That is why a Carfax often shows a fender-bender or an oil change that never touched a title. AutoCheck is owned by Experian, which also owns a large slice of the wholesale auction pipeline, so it sees where a car has been bought and sold at auction and how many times.

  • Buying a one-owner car from a private seller with service receipts? Carfax sees more.
  • Buying an ex-rental, ex-fleet, or anything that passed through Manheim/Copart? AutoCheck sees more.
  • Screening several cars before you shortlist? Neither price makes sense — start with the federal layer.

What the AutoCheck Score actually means

The AutoCheck Score is Experian's 1–100 rating that compares a vehicle against others of the same class and age. It is a convenience, not a verdict: it compresses title brands, auction frequency and reported damage into one number, and it can look reassuring on a car with problems that were simply never reported.

Carfax has no equivalent score. CleanVins publishes a plain-language risk summary that names the specific records driving it rather than an opaque number.

Where the $9.99 option fits

CleanVins licenses the same NMVTIS title, salvage and total-loss feed both incumbents use, pulls live NHTSA recalls, surfaces Copart and IAAI auction records, and rebuilds the original Monroney window sticker — for $9.99 with no subscription. It adds service records from 12,000+ repair shops, but Carfax's insurance and repair-shop network is still larger, and we say so plainly.

The practical workflow most buyers land on: screen every candidate car with the cheap report, then spend on a Carfax only for the single car you are about to buy, if its history hints at collision repair.

From the founder

I started CleanVins because a vehicle history report shouldn't cost $49.99. The title, salvage and recall data behind it comes from federal sources — NHTSA and NMVTIS — so we charge $9.99 once, with no subscription, and put the free checks in front of the paywall where they belong.

— Nolan Shin, Founder & CEO, CleanVins

Related: Full three-way comparison · Best Carfax alternatives for 2027 · What is the cheapest vehicle history report? · Run a free VIN decode

Pricing

Free: VIN decoding and NHTSA safety recall lookups, unlimited, no signup and no credit card. Paid: a full vehicle history report is $9.99 for one VIN, $14.99 for a 3-report pack and $24.99 for a 10-report pack. One-time payment, no subscription and no auto-renewal.

Frequently asked questions

Is Carfax or AutoCheck better?

Neither is better across the board. Carfax ($49.99) wins on insurance-reported accidents and dealer service history. AutoCheck ($29.99) wins on auction and ex-fleet history and adds the AutoCheck Score. Pick based on where the car came from, not on brand name.

Do Carfax and AutoCheck use the same data?

They share the federal layer — NHTSA vPIC build data, NMVTIS title brands and salvage records, and NICB theft records. Their private accident, service and auction networks are separate and do not overlap fully, which is why the same VIN can return different histories.

Which is cheaper, Carfax or AutoCheck?

AutoCheck is cheaper at $29.99 per report versus $49.99 for Carfax. CleanVins is cheaper than both at $9.99 per report, or $14.99 for three.

Can a dealer show me a free Carfax or AutoCheck?

Yes. Most franchise dealers buy reports in bulk and will hand you one free on any listed used car. Always ask before paying. For private-party sales, no free version of either report exists.

Do I still need an inspection if I buy both reports?

Yes. Every history report only shows what somebody reported on paper. A $100–150 pre-purchase inspection by an independent mechanic catches unreported collision repair, frame damage and pending mechanical failures that no report can see.

Data sources

CleanVins is not affiliated with Carfax, AutoCheck, NHTSA or NMVTIS.